F1 News, Reports and Race Results

Steiner wants 50/50 penalty decisions to be dismissed by stewards

Haas boss Guenther Steiner says a fifty/fifty stance by the stewards on a potential penalty decision should simply be dismissed

A five-second penalty handed to Sebastian Vettel in the Canadian Grand Prix sparked controversy among fans and the motorsport community, with Ferrari requesting a review of the stewards' disputed call which will be conducted on Friday at Paul Ricard.

Addressing the events from Montreal, Steiner suggests that when a contentious move is too close to call by the stewards it should simply be ignored, which in turn would also prevent potentially lengthy appeals or useless reviews.

"When you make decisions and you don’t know what to do because it’s a fifty-fifty, they should not give a penalty, because Mercedes could not come back and demand a penalty. That is not in the rules.

"If there is no penalty given you cannot go back and demand a penalty for somebody. To avoid this, a fifty-fifty, we shouldn’t put them in there.

"You start a process which you never finish - you will always find an excuse and it’s a never-ending saga."

Steiner made clear that in his view, the Vettel-Hamilton incident in Montreal was a precisely fifty/fifty case and one he also labeled as "proper racing".

"How I see it, it’s a fifty-fifty and it can go both ways," he added.

"And if it’s a fifty-fifty, I go without the penalty as I always say. Whether it’s against us or for us, we shouldn’t over-regulate it. If it’s a fifty-fifty, let it go.

"That should be the clear decision in my opinion. If it’s a 60-40, again it’s very close. But it was a fifty-fifty in my opinion and it was proper racing.

"If we want to kill racing, if you have to have a simulation before the race and decide the race, we need to stop this. We have no value in this anymore in this one.

"For me it was proper racing, it was pretty cool and in the end, he got the penalty and they need to deal with it, I have no input there thank god. It’s a bit of a contentious one."

To clarify things, Steiner suggests the fifty/fifty assessment should be inscribed in the sporting rules.

"Could we also have a clear rule that if it’s a fifty-fifty we don’t give a penalty? I don’t want to be cheeky here but that could be one of the rules," he said.

Gallery: The beautiful wives and girlfriends of F1 drivers

Keep up to date with all the F1 news via Facebook and Twitter

Michael Delaney

Recent Posts

How Hadjar engineered his leap to ‘weird’ Red Bull seat

During his 2025 rookie season in F1, Isack Hadjar carried himself with a calm, almost…

2 hours ago

Horner in Jerez: Surprise MotoGP visit sparks ownership rumors

The asphalt at Jerez was already sizzling on Saturday, but the temperature in the MotoGP…

19 hours ago

Michele Alboreto: Ferrari's last Italian winner

On this day in 2001, the world of motorsport mourned the loss of Michele Alboreto,…

21 hours ago

Ouch! Alesi spins vintage F1 Ferrari into Monaco barrier

Former Grand Prix driver Jean Alesi, who famously wore his heart on his sleeve during…

23 hours ago

Montoya’s shock call: Ban Verstappen from GT3 racing!

Former F1 driver Juan Pablo Montoya has called out Red Bull for letting Max Verstappen…

24 hours ago

‘Starting to pay off’: Sainz encouraged by positive step for Williams

While the start of the 2026 season has been a heavy lift for Williams –…

1 day ago