F1 News, Reports and Race Results

Coulthard: 'Nervous' F1 stewards taking 'overcautious' decisions

David Coulthard believes extreme apprehension is leading F1's race control and the FIA stewards to take "overcautious" decisions in the heat of the moment.

Last weekend's Australian Grand Prix was marked by none less than three red flags, two of which were debatable according to many drivers.

In the first instance, the race was stopped in the wake of Alex Albon's crash to allow for a proper clean-up after the Williams had scattered gravel onto the track.

George Russell, who was ordered to pit by his Mercedes crew as soon as the safety car was called out, simply couldn't understand why the red flag decision had been made, if not simply for the need for Formula 1 to 'put on a show' to entertain the fans.

"I don't really know what's going on with some of the decisions at the moment," he said. "We're all trying to work together with the FIA to improve things, but it's seemingly a bit of a challenge."

In the second incident of the day, following Kevin Magnussen's brush with the wall that led to debris on the track, race control also opted to halt proceedings with just four laps to go, a decision that baffled Max Verstappen.

"What the f**k! We don’t need a red flag," quipped the Dutchman over the radio.

"I don’t think we needed that second red flag, I think that could have been done with a Virtual Safety Car or a Safety Car at worst," Verstappen commented after the race.

"We’ll talk about it, I think it left a lot of drivers confused about why we needed a red flag."

Coulthard reckons that F1's race director Niels Wittich and those officiating in the stewards' room have become so fearful and jittery of their actions that they are taking an "overcautious" approach to their decisions.

"I think okay he hit the wall, he got a puncture, there’s a little bit of debris on the track, but I just don’t see the red flag in that," the Scot told Channel 4, referring to Magnussen's slip-up.

"And this is really what’s too confusing for me.

"It’s almost like… it’s a difficult job, let’s get it, the referee is always going to be in a difficult situation and in this case of course it’s the stewards and the race director.

"But it’s like they’re so nervous of making a wrong decision, they’re just taking the overcautious decision every time.

"A full Safety Car would have handled that in my opinion."

Coulthard's Channel 4 colleague Mark Webber also questioned the necessity to deploy the red flag for the incident involving Magnussen given that it occurred just a few laps from the checkered flag.

"I think that Magnussen’s crash was unfortunate timing," said Webber. "You’re right on that bubble of having a ‘do we need a restart? Can we finish the race at that point?’

"So yeah, I don’t know. I don’t like rolling the jeopardy card too much because these are the best guys in the world, and I think for them to go down there, we saw the result on cold tyres.

"One lap, bang. They go down there and that’s on Soft tyres, you know, so it wasn’t a good result, and I think the drivers were probably a bit frustrated with how that was handled."

Keep up to date with all the F1 news via Facebook and Twitter

Phillip van Osten

Motor racing was a backdrop from the outset in Phillip van Osten's life. Born in Southern California, Phillip grew up with the sights and sounds of fast cars thanks to his father, Dick van Osten, an editor and writer for Auto Speed and Sport and Motor Trend. Phillip's passion for racing grew even more when his family moved to Europe and he became acquainted with the extraordinary world of Grand Prix racing. He was an early contributor to the monthly French F1i Magazine, often providing a historic or business perspective on Formula 1's affairs. In 2012, he co-authored along with fellow journalist Pierre Van Vliet the English-language adaptation of a limited edition book devoted to the great Belgian driver Jacky Ickx. He also authored "The American Legacy in Formula 1", a book which recounts the trials and tribulations of American drivers in Grand Prix racing. Phillip is also a commentator for Belgian broadcaster Be.TV for the US Indycar series.

Recent Posts

Sebastian Montoya steps up to Formula 2 with Prema

Sebastian Montoya, the 19-year-old son of former Formula 1 star Juan Pablo Montoya, is set…

12 hours ago

Sauber finds its ‘Northern Star’ under Binotto’s leadership

When former Ferrari team principal Mattia Binotto took on the role of Chief Operating Officer…

13 hours ago

Leclerc hails a season ‘without missed opportunities' in 2024

Charles Leclerc concluded the 2024 F1 season with a sense of satisfaction, the Ferrari driver…

15 hours ago

Coulthard sounds alarm over FIA president’s rift with F1 drivers

Former Formula 1 driver David Coulthard has voiced his dismay at FIA president Mohammed Ben…

17 hours ago

The rapid rise and fall of Super Aguri in F1

Super Aguri's application to join Formula 1 became a reality on this day in 2005,…

18 hours ago

Ferrari's 2024 Season: Marked improvement and a fight to the finish

Ferrari roared back into contention in 2024 to deliver their strongest season in years, thanks…

19 hours ago