Coulthard brands Aston Martin’s Newey move an ‘own goal’

The Formula 1 paddock thrives on bold decisions – but sometimes, bold tips into baffling. And according to David Coulthard, Aston Martin did exactly that when it elevated design genius Adrian Newey to team principal.

What was initially framed as a power move – putting one of the sport’s greatest technical minds at the helm – has quickly come under scrutiny as Aston Martin’s 2026 campaign has spiraled into frustration.

Reliability issues tied to the Honda power unit, including severe vibrations, have left drivers Fernando Alonso and Lance Stroll battling more than just rivals.

And now, Coulthard has weighed in – with a dose of bluntness.

‘Never seen him as a team principal’

Few know Newey’s brilliance better than Coulthard, who worked alongside him during his own F1 career, at McLaren and then Red Bull. But that familiarity is precisely why the Scot is raising eyebrows.

“I, having spent most of my career working with Adrian, would never have seen him as a team principal,” said Coulthard.

“He is technically driven, he’s a racer, he is a problem solver from a technical point of view.”

That’s the core of the argument: Newey’s genius lies in design, not diplomacy. And in modern Formula 1, the team principal role demands as much political finesse as technical understanding.

“The politics of Formula 1, which is what the team principal has to deal with a lot, and the politics which are sometimes created with the media as well, is not at all; and especially at Adrian’s stage of life in his 60s,” the Scot said.

“You’ll find as you go through the decades, there are certain things that you’re prepared to do that you’re not prepared to do as you get a bit older, because you’ve got less runway ahead than behind.”

A PR ‘own goal’ for Aston

The bigger issue, in Coulthard’s view, isn’t just the role – it’s how it’s been handled publicly. Backed by team owner Lawrence Stroll, the move was pitched as part of a long-term vision. But the messaging, Coulthard suggests, may have backfired.

“That is a long term play, so I’m curious beyond the statement that we got from Lawrence Stroll that was reaffirming that Adrian is a partner in the team,” he said.

“He’s got a shareholding and they’re going forward together with the original plan, I think it’s just a readdressing of what was a short-term, and actually, what has turned out to be a bit of a PR own goal, because it created a scenario of questioning from the majority of people who were questioning, ‘does that really work?’.

“Now, it’s kind of like, as we thought, it was never going to work.”

• Read also: Lawrence Stroll’s curious defense of Newey and denial of the obvious

None of this diminishes Newey’s legacy. His record as a designer is virtually unmatched, and his fingerprints are all over some of the most dominant cars in F1 history.

But as Aston Martin wrestles with a troubled season, the question now isn’t about his brilliance – it’s about whether it’s being used in the right place.

Coulthard’s verdict is clear: sometimes, even in Formula 1, putting your best player in the wrong position can cost you the game.

Keep up to date with all the F1 news via X and Facebook