F1 News, Reports and Race Results

Steiner pushes for 'professional stewards' after unjust Monaco call

Haas team boss Guenther Steiner questioned the officials' decision to penalize Nico Hulkenberg in last weekend's Monaco Grand Prix and called on F1 to consider relying on a panel of professional stewards in the future.

Hulkenberg was hit with a 5-second penalty for causing a collision on the opening lap of last Sunday's race when lunged down the inside of the Williams of Logan Sargeant at Mirabeau.

Unfortunately, the stewards were not satisfied with how Hulkenberg's penalty was served during his pitstop, so they duly sanctioned the Haas charger with a second 10-second penalty.

It all amounted to a lot of frustration in the US outfit's camp. On Thursday, ahead of this weekend's Spanish Grand Prix in Barcelona, Steiner was still reeling over the stewards' seemingly unjust call.

"I think it's [turn] six when they are in the line, and the Aston Martin is front. I looked at the pictures and Nico comes from the inside and dives into the corner, but I can't see a collision," Steiner explained.

"I'm told that a collision is touching, but I'm still trying to find out. I'm still trying to get it explained because I think it was completely wrong."

Read also:

While no physical contact between Hulkenberg and Sargeant was visible on the pair's onboard footage, the Haas driver was informed over the radio that he had picked up a puncture, which suggests that a touch, however light it may have been, had perhaps occurred between the two cars.

However, the German's pit stop at the end of the opening lap was a planned event according to his team.

"This has consequences," added a discontent Steiner. "Lap one, we get a penalty for what I think is not a collision, then there is other people running into each other during the race and they get a black and white flag. So I think it's very inconsistent.

"Then we look at the accident in Miami between de Vries and Norris in lap one, that was no collision? If a collision is because you attack somebody, and he reacts to it, why would you get a penalty for that?

"I still don't understand it. And I was told in the video that you can see a collision, I looked at numerous pictures and I cannot see a collision.

"If somebody wants to tell me there is a collision, how can you be sure? And if you don't know if it is one or not, what is it then? Innocent until proven guilty? Not 'guilty until proven innocent' in my opinion."

In order to improve the consistency of the stewards' calls, Steiner tabled the idea of F1 relying, like in other sports, on a panel of dedicated professional individuals that officiate at every race rather than on its current system of rotating stewards.

"We need a different system for F1 stewards in my opinion, because every other professional sport has got professionals being referees and stuff like this," he said.

"F1 is one of the biggest sports in the world and we still have laymen deciding on the fate of people who invest millions in their careers. It's always a discussion because there's no consistency.

"In American racing - NASCAR and IndyCar - how many times do you hear problems with the stewards or race directors decisions? Very rarely.

"But they're doing it completely differently because there is full-time people working there."

Keep up to date with all the F1 news via Facebook and Twitter

Phillip van Osten

Motor racing was a backdrop from the outset in Phillip van Osten's life. Born in Southern California, Phillip grew up with the sights and sounds of fast cars thanks to his father, Dick van Osten, an editor and writer for Auto Speed and Sport and Motor Trend. Phillip's passion for racing grew even more when his family moved to Europe and he became acquainted with the extraordinary world of Grand Prix racing. He was an early contributor to the monthly French F1i Magazine, often providing a historic or business perspective on Formula 1's affairs. In 2012, he co-authored along with fellow journalist Pierre Van Vliet the English-language adaptation of a limited edition book devoted to the great Belgian driver Jacky Ickx. He also authored "The American Legacy in Formula 1", a book which recounts the trials and tribulations of American drivers in Grand Prix racing. Phillip is also a commentator for Belgian broadcaster Be.TV for the US Indycar series.

Recent Posts

Red Bull chief denounces Wolff’s public pursuit of Verstappen

Red Bull managing director Oliver Mintzlaff has sharply criticized Toto Wolff’s public pursuit of Max…

27 mins ago

FIA Stewards reject Aston Martin’s right of review for China Sprint

The FIA has dismissed the Aston Martin F1 team’s request for a right of review…

1 hour ago

Norris wishes for a do-over on Saturday set-up changes

Lando Norris admitted that he wishes the team hadn't decided to make the changes to…

2 hours ago

Miami GP: Saturday's action in pictures

Another qualifying session, another pole position for Max Verstappen. In Miami, the Red Bull charger…

10 hours ago

Russell: Mercedes has ‘overcompensated’ for 2023 car’s issues

George Russell believes that Mercedes’ struggles this season are rooted in the team “overcompensating” for…

10 hours ago

Leclerc 'on the limit' in quali but couldn't catch Verstappen

Charles Leclerc insisted that he was driving right on the limit in Saturday's qualifying session…

11 hours ago