F1 News, Reports and Race Results

Wurz blames Vettel penalty on F1's 'strive for perfection'

GPDA chairman Alex Wurz says Formula 1's quest for "the ultimate perfection" with regard to the interpretation of the sport's rules is to blame for the controversial penalty handed to Sebastian Vettel in Sunday's Canadian Grand Prix.

The ex-F1 Benetton and Williams driver, who now guides the efforts of the Grand Prix Drivers Association, believes that over the years, drivers and teams have demanded so much clarity and precision from the FIA that cases are no longer judged on the basis of their individual merits.

"Each and everyone in the system who thinks this penalty is not justified is at fault because over the years, with all these incidents and cases, the drivers and team managers asked the FIA in the open way of discussion for clarification of what is allowed and not - down to millimetre and micrometer movements," Wurz explained.

"In this whole process over the years, that is where we arrived.

"The just, rational decision of looking at a situation and making a decision based on, yes, underlying rules, but not in such fragmented, small little details, has gone.

"So it is hard to blame the FIA and the stewards for this, and this is what I don't like in the conversation - that it goes a bit personal in this whole debate.

"We are an industry that strives for the ultimate perfection, advantage or disadvantage and penalty or not penalty.

"So we arrive at such a situation. One struggles almost to judge one situation without having to refer to six or 10 other similar situations.

"In reality each and every situation is different because there are so many influences."

Wurz believes Vettel did not commit any offense, but the underlying rules, a recourse to precedents and the need to be consistent, made it impossible for the stewards not to punish the Ferrari driver.

"You could see it was sort of physics, going over grass, correcting the car until well back on track in a logical trajectory. Hence it wasn't intentional to close the door and squeeze Lewis," added the Austrian.

"Of course, if you push it to the limit, one driver makes a mistake, if the mistake is in front of you, you have to react.

"If you make it by, great, if you don't make it by, missed opportunity. It's the name of the game. It's racing.

"I was of the same opinion when Max Verstappen in Suzuka last year went over the Astroturf - which is a bit more slippery, there is more dust - he came back, he slid to the other side of the track, there is Kimi Raikkonen wanting to go on the outside and they touched. Max got a five-second penalty.

"When you look at this, you say, 'Ah, well the FIA is in this case quite consistent on rejoining the track dangerously regardless of whether it's in your capability to control or not.

"They have decided it is a five-second penalty'.

"Vettel has a certain speed going off into the grass. Of course at a certain point he will put the power back on, because he wants to continue his race. And that's his right to do.

"I don't think he drove in front of Lewis intentionally as aggressive as it might look on TV because his head moves to look in the mirror, after the correction is finished.

"Therefore I would have not seen it as action to be penalised, very much as I would have not penalised Verstappen in Suzuka either.

"However, both cases are very similar and FIA gave the same penalty, so we have to accept that."

Gallery: The beautiful wives and girlfriends of F1 drivers

Keep up to date with all the F1 news via Facebook and Twitter

Phillip van Osten

Motor racing was a backdrop from the outset in Phillip van Osten's life. Born in Southern California, Phillip grew up with the sights and sounds of fast cars thanks to his father, Dick van Osten, an editor and writer for Auto Speed and Sport and Motor Trend. Phillip's passion for racing grew even more when his family moved to Europe and he became acquainted with the extraordinary world of Grand Prix racing. He was an early contributor to the monthly French F1i Magazine, often providing a historic or business perspective on Formula 1's affairs. In 2012, he co-authored along with fellow journalist Pierre Van Vliet the English-language adaptation of a limited edition book devoted to the great Belgian driver Jacky Ickx. He also authored "The American Legacy in Formula 1", a book which recounts the trials and tribulations of American drivers in Grand Prix racing. Phillip is also a commentator for Belgian broadcaster Be.TV for the US Indycar series.

Recent Posts

Tost warns Lawson: ‘Do your own thing’ at Red Bull

Former AlphaTauri team principal Franz Tost has cautioned Liam Lawson to tread carefully next season…

10 hours ago

Montoya: Piastri the driver ‘with the most to prove’ in 2025

Former Formula 1 driver and Grand Prix winner Juan Pablo Montoya believes McLaren’s Oscar Piastri…

12 hours ago

Africa’s F1 dreams spark rivalry between South Africa and Rwanda

The race to return Formula 1 to the African continent is heating up, with South…

14 hours ago

James Garner and Lorenzo Bandini get ready to roll

Two commemorative dates come together on this day, and both are embodied by this picture…

15 hours ago

Red Bull’s 2024 Season: Cracks in the armor amid Max's brilliance

Red Bull Racing's 2024 F1 season presented a stark contrast to their crushing, near-perfect 2023…

16 hours ago

Vasseur confirms Ferrari 2025 contender 99% ‘all-new’

Ferrari team principal Fred Vasseur has revealed that the Scuderia’s 2025 Formula 1 car, code-named…

17 hours ago