F1 News, Reports and Race Results

Ferrari seeking 'clarity' over FIA's car copying rules

Ferrari says that it is seeking 'clarity and transparency over what's allowed in the sport under the FIA's current regulations governing the copying of car designs.

Racing Point caused a stir at pre-season testing when its 2020 car appeared to be a close copy of last year's Mercedes. A formal protest was subsequently lodged against the design by Renault and upheld by the FIA.

However the penalty imposed by the governing body - a fine of €400,000 and the loss of 15 championship points - had been criticised by rival teams, as it allows Racing Point to continue using the current controversial brake duct design at the centre of the protest for the rest of the year despite having been deemed 'illegal'.

Ferrari has formally appealed the FIA's original ruling, but the team insists that it is motivated by the need to understand the thinking behind the decision.

“The reason why we have confirmed our appeal, I think it’s because we need to seek clarification and transparency,” Binotto said according to Motorsport.com this week.

“I think the brake duct is a point," he continued. "But I think that eventually the decision of the International Court of Appeal [will] open up a more wider and broader discussion on the carbon copy car concept, which for us is important.

“It’s important as well for the future of the Formula 1," he insisted. "At the end [of the day] it’s about discussing intellectual property, and I think that intellectual property is a very important asset of a company."

“If someone would somehow copy almost an identical car of the previous year of a competitor, I think the regulations should somehow protect the competitor itself.

“That’s why I think at the moment it’s important simply to move forward and understand," he added. "The fairness of the competition and for the future of Formula 1 is important."

Ferrari itself went to great lengths to protect the design of its 2019 engine after a secret settlement with the FIA over the off-season about its legality.

Racing Point insists that the design of the RP20 was reverse-engineered from intensive study of publicly available photographs of last year's title-winning W10, rather than relying on 'insider information' from Mercedes who supply the team's power units.

However the protest was centred on the brake ducts which are normally hard to photograph.

Either way, the FIA has said that the sport's regulations will be changed so that this copycat approach to car design will be outlawed in 2021.

New rules will “expressly prevent teams from using photography or other reverse engineering techniques to copy large parts of other teams' cars" said FIA secretary general for sport Peter Bayer in a message sent to all ten teams.

Gallery: The beautiful wives and girlfriends of F1 drivers

Keep up to date with all the F1 news via Facebook and Twitter

Andrew Lewin

Andrew first became a fan of Formula 1 during the time when Michael Schumacher and Damon Hill were stepping into the limelight after the era of Alain Prost, Nigel Mansell and Aryton Senna. He's been addicted ever since, and has been writing about the sport now for nearly a quarter of a century for a number of online news sites. He's also written professionally about GP2 (now Formula 2), GP3, IndyCar, World Rally Championship, MotoGP and NASCAR. In his other professional life, Andrew is a freelance writer, social media consultant, web developer/programmer, and digital specialist in the fields of accessibility, usability, IA, online communities and public sector procurement. He worked for many years in magazine production at Bauer Media, and for over a decade he was part of the digital media team at the UK government's communications department. Born and raised in Essex, Andrew currently lives and works in south-west London.

Recent Posts

F1i's Driver Ratings for the 2024 São Paulo GP

Alexander Albon, Williams (Did Not Start): 5.5/10 Alex Albon is definitely going through something of…

2 hours ago

Jos Verstappen rips British media after Brazilian Max fest

Jos Verstappen wasted no time after his son spectacular win at the São Paulo Grand…

3 hours ago

Leclerc left with ‘mixed feelings’ after disappointing Sao Paulo GP

Charles Leclerc's weekend in Sao Paulo was unfortunately a stark contrast to Ferrari's recent triumphs…

5 hours ago

Back when Kimi knew exactly what he was doing

Twelve years ago on this day, Kimi Raikkonen took a popular win at the 2012…

7 hours ago

Mercedes fined for starting grid tyre pressure infringement

The Mercedes team was hit with a fine by the FIA after Sunday’s Sao Paulo…

7 hours ago

Hamilton’s woes deepen after battling ‘plank of wood’ car in Brazil

Despite his best efforts, a lowly tenth-place finish was as good as it got for…

9 hours ago