F1 News, Reports and Race Results

Wolff: Mercedes would have won appeal 'in regular court'

Mercedes team principal Toto Wolff believes that his team had been almost "guaranteed" to win its appeal against the result of the Abu Dhabi Grand Prix if the hearing had been held in a regular court.

But Wolff admitted that things had looked a lot less promising for them in the FIA International Court of Appeal and the Court of Arbitration for Sport, which is why they ultimately decided not to proceed with the action rather than for any fear of losing the argument itself.

"We believe we had a very strong case if you look at it from the legal side," Wolff told a group fo media representatives on Friday. "If it would have been judged in a regular court, it is almost guaranteed that we would have won.

"But the problem with the ICA is the way it's structured. The FIA can't really mark their own homework," he complained. "And there's a difference between being right and obtaining justice.

“I don’t think that at the moment we are set up in terms of our governance to end up in a situation that would have given us a remedy that would have reinstalled the result that was taken away from Lewis before the last lap of the race.

"That’s why, heavy-hearted, we decided not to appeal because we wouldn’t have gotten the result back," he stated, adding that Lewis Hamilton had been involved in and supported the teams' action at every stage of the process.

“Every step of the way it was joint decisions,” Wolff said. “We decided together with Lewis to protest, to launch the appeal and to withdraw the appeal.

"As you can imagine, not only for him but also for us as a team, it was terrible to be confronted with a decision that decided the outcome of the world championship.

“Nobody of us, neither him or us, want to win a world championship in the courtroom," he added. “But it was tremendously hard for him and for us as a team to withdraw the appeal, because we were deeply wronged.

"It wasn’t just a case of a bad call, it was freestyle reading of the rules and it left Lewis like a sitting duck," he said. "There is a lesson to be learned in how can we make sure that going forward, in situations like that, that the right decisions are being taken.

"The verdict from the stewards in response for regulations and judgment in the courts, whether it is the ICA or the CAS, which is not currently part of the legislations, can be judged in a way that is fair and neutral to every participant."

Wolff said he had been proud of the support he had received from the team's sponsors and business partners. “They’ve been with us all the way along.

“The message that I have received personally from sponsors, from fans, from very credible people made me very happy," he added. “The sponsors have trusted us to come up with a decision in relation to the appeal and would have gone with us all the way."

The sport's governing body has already announced a detailed analysis of the events of Sunday night at Yas Marina, and of the decisions that race control made to ensure the race finished with a thrilling single lap shoot-out rather than behind the safety car.

“The decisions that have been taken in the last four minutes of this race have robbed Lewis Hamilton of a deserved world championship,” Wolff said, clearly still fuming over the events. “Robbing him in the last lap of the race is unacceptable.”

"We expect the commission to not only come up with words but with actions," stressed Wolff. "We will hold them accountable for the actions.

"We cannot continue in a sport that is meant to be sport followed by entertainment, and not the other way around, that we are held ransom by ad hoc decisions.

"There needs to be clear measures in place before the start of next season [so that] every driver, every team and the fans understand what's on and what is not on."

One person at the heart at the storm is racing director Michael Masi, whose on-the-fly decisions about how to handle the restart have been under fire from all sides and whose position could now be under threat over the winter.

“I am not interested in having a conversation with Michael Masi,” Wolff said bluntly. "Robbing [Lewis] in the last lap of the race is unacceptable.

"That's why from a personal standpoint, from a professional standpoint I cannot," he added. "My values and my sense of integrity just isn’t compatible with the decisions that have been made on Sunday, so it is up to the FIA to decide going forward how these decisions, how these situations can be avoided.”

Gallery: The beautiful wives and girlfriends of F1 drivers

Keep up to date with all the F1 news via Facebook and Twitter

Andrew Lewin

Andrew first became a fan of Formula 1 during the time when Michael Schumacher and Damon Hill were stepping into the limelight after the era of Alain Prost, Nigel Mansell and Aryton Senna. He's been addicted ever since, and has been writing about the sport now for nearly a quarter of a century for a number of online news sites. He's also written professionally about GP2 (now Formula 2), GP3, IndyCar, World Rally Championship, MotoGP and NASCAR. In his other professional life, Andrew is a freelance writer, social media consultant, web developer/programmer, and digital specialist in the fields of accessibility, usability, IA, online communities and public sector procurement. He worked for many years in magazine production at Bauer Media, and for over a decade he was part of the digital media team at the UK government's communications department. Born and raised in Essex, Andrew currently lives and works in south-west London.

Recent Posts

Button: Maiden F1 win won’t change the way Norris goes racing

Jenson Button believes the core of Lando Norris’ racing style will not change following the…

7 mins ago

Ford unfazed by Newey exit: Commitment to Red Bull ‘unchanged’

Ford says its commitment to Red Bull’s engine programme remains “unchanged” despite renowned designer Adrian…

2 hours ago

Hulme's first F1 win, overshadowed by tragedy

Denny Hulme clinched his first Grand Prix win on this day at Monaco in 1967,…

3 hours ago

Abbi pulling her weight in F1 Academy

Alpine protégé Abbi Pulling extended her lead in the F1 Academy championship with back-to-back wins…

4 hours ago

Wolff dismisses Mintzlaff criticism: ‘No relevance for me’

Toto Wolff has dismissed Red Bull chief Oliver Mintzlaff’s criticism of the Mercedes team principal’s…

5 hours ago

Race ban looms for Magnussen after penalty-filled Miami weekend

Kevin Magnussen’s defensive tactics and a clash with a mid-field rival in the Miami Grand…

6 hours ago